Coolest Birthday CakesCake Decorating Contest

Coolest Eyeball Cake 9

by Beth T.
(Boone, NC)

Homemade Eyeball Cake

Homemade Eyeball Cake

Every year we have a Halloween party, so this year I wanted to do something different for dessert. After looking at multiple websites I found an Eyeball Cake on here I thought would be fun.

I used a red velvet cake mix so it would look like blood after being cut. I baked the cake in a large glass mixing bowl for approximately one hour until done in center. Once cooled I cut out a center hole about half the depth of the cake for the iris and pupil area. I then covered the entire cake with buttercream and white fondant making sure I formed it into the cut hole.

I poured green jello that had not set into the hole area and refrigerated it until almost set. I then used a toothpick and mixed all the food coloring liquid together to make a dark color(almost black). I used the color and toothpick to pull through the jello to make the pupil and lines in the iris. I then used red jello and poured it over the entire cake and used red food coloring to make the veins. I used a decorating brush for this.

I then used some more of the dark color liquid to make the "Blood" in the dish darker. I returned the entire cake to the refrigerator to set for several hours. This cake was a huge hit at the party. When we cut it, the jello oozed out and the red velvet gave it a nice gross look, but was tasty.

Click here to post comments

Return to Other Birthday Cakes 5.

Coolest Eye Cake 3

by Amanda Lowe
(Salida, CA)

Eye Cake

Eye Cake

I saw these eye cakes in a magazine and thought I should try it. So easy and really fun! Using unglazed donut holes (holds frosting really well) and M&Ms these are great for a Halloween party.

After looking at the grocery stores for weeks I was unable to find unglazed donut holes. So I went to the local donut store and ordered a few dozen holes unglazed. (Check, because I needed to give them a few days notice before I picked them up).

I used a can of white frosting and melted it a little in the microwave. Just a few seconds, you want it workable, not soup. I then dipped each donut in the frosting coating it, and set it on a wire wrack to cool and harden. I immediately (before it cooled) placed an M&M on backward (so the M&M did not show). (TIP: only use eye colors of M&Ms ex: blue, green, brown. Red, yellow, orange does not look as real.) Because red frosting is so hard to make I bought a tube of it, which made it extremely easy to draw on the lines of the eyes.

Place in a bowl and serve! These were a huge hit at my husbands work Halloween party.

Comments for Coolest Eye Cake 3

Click here to add your own comments

Love it!
by: Christine

I use to make something like this but out of a family cookie recipe but I LOVE your idea so much better! I'm just going to have to try it these this Halloween! Great idea!

cake donuts?
by: Marcia

Do you mean that you use cake donut holes when you say unglazed? If so, thanks! This looks really neat and easy and kids would love it.

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Other Birthday Cakes 5.

Coolest Eyeball Cake 8

by Ken
(Natick, MA)

Homemade  Eyeball Cake

Homemade Eyeball Cake

I made this Eyeball Cake for my stepson's 8th birthday. This is actually the practice cake, as I have never worked with fondant before. He said he wanted a Cyclops cake, so this is the cake. There will also be a 18 inch cyclops made from rice cereal treats and modeling chocolate (never used those before either) standing next to the cake.

I started with 2 sheet cakes, stacked and cut to shape. I added a round piece of cake on top to define the pupil and iris. I rolled white fondant for the middle of the eye, brown fondant for the eyelids, and black for the pupil and lashes. I finished with a purple fondant for the iris. I brushed the pupil and iris with water, which after drying left a nice shine that you can see in the picture. I used ready made red tubed icing for the blood shot effect.

I don't generally draw things out before I do them, so this was done "off the cuff". I hope you like it. When I make the final cake with the cyclops, I will upload a picture.

Comments for Coolest Eyeball Cake 8

Click here to add your own comments

Beautiful Cake
by: Anonymous

Dear Ken,

Your cake has truly inspired my partner, Yu, and I to follow our dreams when it comes to cake-making. We are required to make an eyeball cake and your artistic, wonderful work has been a life changing moment for the both of us. I truly thank you from the bottom of my heart as you have showed me that anybody can follow their dreams. You are my idol.


Cho and Yu

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Other Birthday Cakes 5.