Coolest Birthday CakesCake Decorating Contest

Coolest Garfield Cake 14

by Kathryn
(Loveland, CO)

Homemade Garfield Cake

Homemade Garfield Cake

Homemade Garfield Cake
Homemade Garfield Cake

I made this Homemade Garfield Cake for my granddaughter’s seventh birthday. This cake was actually how I found this site, it was created based on a couple of cakes I found right here at coolest-cakes. I created it out of three cake mixes, two baked in a porcelain bowl for the head and body, and one in a 10-inch round pan to construct the paws and tail out of. (The tail ended up covered up with the ‘blanket’.) I was a little dubious about baking in a bowl but it turned out fantastic.

It’s iced with butter cream icing, homemade and a couple of tubs of premixed Wilton decorator icing. We decided to add Pooky with Garfield, he is composed entirely of chocolate fondant with icing eyes and details. We weren’t sure how to create him and I think this came out quite nicely.

Garfield’s blanket is also fondant, rolled thin and trimmed. The ears are cardboard half-circles covered in icing. Details were deceptively simple; coloring the icing was the hardest part! I just used a large round tip with different colors-the whites of the eyes were just some untinted butter cream that I piped on and then smoothed out with a metal spatula. All other details were done with the same tip.

For ease of transport and lack of anything laying around I could use, I constructed the cake on a large baking sheet. If I did it again I’d probably ice the baking sheet first or line it with fondant. This was a lot easier than the last cake I did, which was tiered-I’d rather make this type of character cake any day.

Click here to post comments

Return to Animated Character Cakes 3.

Coolest Garfield Cake Design 13

by Kylie R,
(Melbourne, Australia )

Homemade Garfield Cake Design

Homemade Garfield Cake Design

Homemade Garfield Cake Design
Homemade Garfield Cake Design
Homemade Garfield Cake Design
Homemade Garfield Cake Design

This Homemade Garfield Cake Design was taken from a Debbie Brown cookbook. The cake itself was terrible!! I used a chocolate Madeira cake with Kahlua cream filling (it was for adults). The cake was two bowl cakes shaped into two round balls. They were halved and filled with the Kahlua cream (which was beautiful). Unfortunately the cake turned out VERY dry and was barely eatable - I think this may have been because they had to be cooked in glass bowls.

I also used the Kahlua cream (flavored buttercream) as a base under my fondant before sculpting the Garfield character. The box was made from fondant cut into strips and allowed to sit overnight and then stuck together with fondant glue (previously I have used glucose or royal icing but found the fondant glue to be worth the money spent). Very happy with how it turned out except for the cake!

Comments for Coolest Garfield Cake Design 13

Click here to add your own comments

Fantastic Cake Kylie.R
by: BettyCrocker Inc

Your cake is magnificent! We would like to speak with you about the possibility of a scholarship at our cakeversity over in the USA (9mths Fulltime course)

Please contact me

What a gorgeous cake!
by: Odie

What an amazing job you've done! With a cake that looks as good as that who care's how it tastes! Keep the Kahlua for drinking! ;)

by: Christine

I totally disagree with you Odie.

The cake is magnificent but people will not come back to you again if it tastes rotten. I have a regular stream of requests from people who love the taste of my cakes and are even more delighted if my designs come up to scratch.

C xxx

by: Kylie

Thanks for your feedback.. I have since discovered that the cake recipe I used initially was not very good. You will be happy to know i have since recreated the came cake with my usual recipe and it worked beautifully.. absolute hit with everyone there.


Click here to add your own comments

Return to Animated Character Cakes 3.

Coolest Garfield Birthday Cake 9

by Romina
(Attard, Malta)

Homemade Garfield Birthday Cake

Homemade Garfield Birthday Cake

I did this Garfield Birthday Cake for my daughter's 3rd birthday because she loved to watch Garfield's movies. It is very simple; just bake 2 cakes in 2 oven proof bowls and position them one behind the other. Then cover them with butter icing and with a layer of yellow sugarpaste.

For the blanket, roll out another layer of blue sugarpaste and let it fall gently on the rear cake. Use two white oval discs for the eyes, shape and position the ears and roll a yellow sausage shaped piece of sugarpaste for the mouth.
Finally i painted Garfield's stripes with a little bit of black food colour diluted with some clear alcohol and voila!.

My daughter just couldn't believe her eyes when she saw it.

Comments for Coolest Garfield Birthday Cake 9

Click here to add your own comments

by: Gab

Wow, it's a piece of art. It's incredible!

Garfield Cake No 9
by: Sandra Bowen

Love this cake, wished you lived close enough to bake it for me. It is Awesome!!!!

by: Jenn

This is great! It's exactly what I wanted to do for my daughter's 1st birthday. Hopefully I can do it. Do a trial one first, just to make sure!

love this cake
by: christy love garfield

oh how i wish you would make one for me.. excellent excellent job

by: Garfield Liker

I totally cannot believe it I have always loved Garfield and his friends...I wish I could have a Garfield cake too!

So nice!!
by: Jackie the Garfield fan

How lucky of your daughter to get such an amazing birthday cake!! I wish i had one too

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Animated Character Cakes 4.

Coolest Garfield Cake from "Scratch" 15

by Karen
(Great Falls, VA, USA)

Homemade Garfield Cake from

Homemade Garfield Cake from "Scratch"

My 9 year old son found his Uncle's "vintage" Garfield comic books over the holidays and has been reading nothing else since. When he asked for a Garfield cake for his birthday, I started trying to find Garfield cake pans. There were a few, but none I liked so this is what I came up with. Hope you like it.

DS’ favorite color is blue, which explains the neon blue background. I found a few Garfield cartoon images online but liked this one with the scratches the best. The hardest part was getting the right expression on this cat’s face. Garfield does have a certain look, doesn’t he?

Fun fact: The black icing turns your teeth (and everything else) green.

Click here to post comments

Return to Animated Character Cakes 3.