I made these Homemade Elmo and Cookie Monster Birthday Cakes for my twin boys’ first birthdays. To make these cakes, I used some ideas I found on this website and made it my own!
Elmo: I baked 2 boxed cake mixes in a Kitchen Aid stand mixer bowl for about 1 hr. 45 min at 350 degrees. ( I was nervous about using the bowl but it came out fine). To decorate, I used Wilton red frosting – about 4 tubes, give or take. To get the “fur” look, I dyed coconut: 1 package of Baker’s coconut in a Ziploc storage bag and roughly 1 bottle of red food coloring. Shake until you get the desired color. The eyes are Hostess Snowballs with mini-Oreos stuck on with white frosting, and the nose is also a Hostess Snowball. The mouth is just black icing.
Cookie Monster: I baked 2 boxed chocolate cake mixes in 4 9-inch round cake pans. I only used 3 of the cakes and cut up the 4th for their “smash cakes”. Layer 3 of the cakes as you would for any layer cake. This took a LOT of Wilton Royal Blue frosting – about 6 tubes. Again, I dyed coconut blue and used Snowballs and Oreos for the eyes. I made chocolate chip cookies and stuffed them in between two of the layers. Very easy and cute!
2 thoughts on “Cool Homemade Elmo and Cookie Monster Birthday Cakes”
That’s so cute… They turned out awesome!
Wow, this is the coolest Elmo and Cookie Monster Cakes I have seen. Very creative! I would like to make this and wondered if you had any trouble baking with the kitchen aid mixer bowl? Was it difficult to get the cake out?
Your comment has been sent successfully.