15 Cool Sesame Street Birthday Cakes

Sesame Street Cake Collage

Sesame Street has been one of the most popular TV shows for years and these fuzzy, awesome characters are not going anywhere anytime soon. Take a look at these awesome Sesame Street Cakes and find inspiration for making your own. 1. Cool Oscar Cake and Friends Beth from Novi, MI continued her mom’s tradition of … Read more

1st Birthday Cake with Baby Elmo and Cookie Monster

Sesame Street Cake

This is one of my favorite cakes.  It was for a first birthday – all gumpaste figures. The example cake that the client gave me had plastic figures. We changed everything up a bit and we ended up with gum paste baby Elmo and Cookie Monster. I included a jumbo crayon for the number one … Read more

Simple Sesame Street Cake

Simple Sesame Street Cake

This Sesame Street cake was for my youngest’s 2nd birthday. At this point I was just doing simple cakes. Boxed cake mix and tub frosting. Making homemade cakes became a necessity as the price of store bought cakes became too expensive. I used an 11×15 sheet pan and made 2 cakes (4 boxes of mix).  … Read more

Awesome Sesame Street Birthday Cake for a 2 Year Old Boy

Awesome Sesame Street Birthday Cake for a 2 Year Old Boy

This Sesame Street birthday cake is for my son’s 2nd birthday. It took me 2 days to make this birthday cake. I had to bake 10 boxes of cake at work where I work as a direct care worker with clients. So I was on my feet all day running back and forth, back and … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Band Birthday Cake

Coolest Sesame Street Band Birthday Cake

I just made this Sesame Street Band Birthday Cake for our little man Nathan’s birthday party tomorrow. It consists of six layers of Triple Chocolate Fudge, Strawberry, Lemon Poppy seed,  Cherry Chip and Funfetti. The bottom tier is 1/4 sheet cakes of one layer of Triple Chocolate Fudge and one layer of Lemon Poppy seed filled with chocolate fudge butter cream. The … Read more

A Tasty 2-Year-Old Sesame Street Birthday Cake

A Tasty 2-Year-Old Sesame Street Birthday Cake

This Sesame Street birthday cake is my son’s 2nd birthday cake. He loves Elmo so it was the perfect choice for this birthday!  This cake is a marble mud and absolutely delicious. The bottom part is edible and the top 2 layers are foam so that we can keep them as a keepsake.  The hardest part … Read more

Coolest Cookie Monster and Elmo Cake

Homemade Cookie Monster and Elmo Cake

I made this homemade Cookie Monster and Elmo cake for my nephew’s 1st birthday. I used a 9×13 pan and 3″ ball pan for each head (chocolate chip cake). I made an extra Elmo head (because Elmo is my nephew’s favorite) for the smash cake which actually turned out better than the one on the … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Cake

Sesame Street Cake

This Sesame Street cake was the second tier cake that I had ever made. I was amazed that it came out straight. The top tier is two layers of strawberry cake with red butter cream frosting. My son devoured it. The middle tier was a two layer Swiss chocolate cake with blue butter cream frosting. … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Neighborhood 3rd Birthday Cake 54

Homemade Sesame Street Neighborhood 3rd Birthday Cake

The Sesame Street Neighborhood 3rd Birthday Cake was by FAR the most amount of work for his party, as usual. I am a hobbyist in the cake department, completing usually two a year, one for each child. In preparing a design for the cake, I asked Nate what he would like on it. I was … Read more

Coolest Elmo’s World Cake

Homemade Elmo's World Cake

This Elmo themed cake was made for my son’s 2nd birthday. The top is a double layer cake, with butter cream and marshmallow fondant. We used the Sesame Street cut-out on the site as a stencil for the “Greyson” Sesame Street sign. We emphasized the “2” for his birthday. The sides of the cake have … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Cake

Homemade Sesame Street Cake

This Sesame Street cake was for my daughter’s 2nd birthday. She loved it! I took ideas from a few other cakes on this website and kind of combined them all! I used a glass Pyrex bowl to bake the cakes for Elmo and Cookie Monster! For the frosting I used a buttercream for the bottom … Read more

Coolest Budget Sesame Street Birthday Cake

Homemade Budget Sesame Street Birthday Cake

The cake part of this Homemade Budget Sesame Street Birthday Cake was super easy and cheap. I bought 2 boxes of cake mix (I did strawberry and the confetti-vanilla), and baked each in a 9-inch round pan. For the purple icing, I bought plain grocery store vanilla, colored it with Whitman’s food coloring, and lathered … Read more

Coolest Elmo and Cookie Monster Birthday Cake

Homemade Elmo and Cookie Monster Birthday Cake

I wanted to make my daughter an Elmo cake for her first birthday. I browsed online at photos of amazing cakes but never saw one that caught my eye. I saw similar cakes that just stood with an Elmo using Wilton standing bear cake pan. Then I came across a cake that had two characters.It … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Cake

Sesame Street Cake

I made this Sesame Street cake for my son’s first birthday. It is three tiers of 2 layer cakes, 2 vanilla and 1 chocolate. I used the pre-colored fondant for the bottom and just cut it into equal sized strips. I used jumbo star sprinkles for the middle layer and elmo sugar decorations for the … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Birthday Cake

Homemade Sesame Street Birthday Cake

I made this Sesame Street birthday cake for my son, Brian’s second birthday. I used two 10 inch round pans for the cake itself, iced with butter cream icing. The figures on the top I carved out of pre-colored fondant. My son has little figures that I used as ‘models’ along with pictures from the … Read more

Coolest Elmo And Abby Birthday Cake

Homemade Elmo And Abby Birthday Cake

This Elmo And Abby Birthday Cake was my FIRST time EVER making a cake. I wanted my little girl’s 2nd birthday to be special, and the theme was Elmo and Abby. This is the cake I imagined. I did lots of research on making cakes through various websites, this one included. I made store bought … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street 2nd Birthday Cake

coolest-sesame-street-2nd-birthday-cake-37-21352344.jpg

My twins love Elmo and Sesame Street so I decided to do something along that line for their birthday. After researching this site and the internet, this is what I made. I was very pleased with the results. I used a yellow boxed cake mix and prepared two 9 inch round cakes. I baked them … Read more

Coolest Elmo’s World Birthday Cake

Homemade  Elmo's World Birthday Cake

I made this Homemade Elmo’s World Birthday Cake for my son’s 2nd Birthday. This is my first fondant cake ever, but I’m SO happy with how it turned out. My inspiration for the cake came from Elmo’s World, the show on Sesame Street and the colors from the plates I got for the party. I … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street First Birthday Cake

Homemade Sesame Street First Birthday Cake

I saw a homemade Sesame Street first birthday cake online similar to this one and it was perfect for my granddaughter’s first birthday. I baked three-pound cakes and baked them in 10, 8, and 6-inch pans. Each cake was two layers.I filled the layers with cooked pudding and iced them with homemade butter cream frosting. … Read more

Coolest 1st Birthday Sesame Street Cake

Homemade 1st Birthday Sesame Street Cake

This is the first cake I have ever made like this so I was a little nervous. I looked around online for some ideas and then built this homemade 1st birthday Sesame Street cake. The inside of the cake is tye-dye which is simply a white cake mix separated and colored and then layered in … Read more

Coolest Sesame Street Birthday Cake

Homemade Sesame Street Birthday Cake

I didn’t do my son’s first birthday justice, so I wanted to do something a bit more special this time around. I got lots of inspiration from this site and decided to attempt a tiered fondant cake. I checked out a few other sites for tips and techniques and decided to give it a shot, … Read more

Coolest Elmo & Cookie Monster Cake

Homemade Elmo & Cookie Monster Cake

This Homemade Elmo & Cookie Monster Cake was, hands down the most awesome cake I’ve ever done. I sculpted the heads out of rice crispy treats and the bodies were carved entirely from cake. I used a grass tip for Elmo’s fur and a basket tip for Cookie Monster’s fur. The eyes and noses were … Read more