I was doing a search for Thanksgiving themed cupcakes my son and I could make to bring to my mom for the holiday. I came across some really cool ones with mini turkeys (a little to elaborate for me to do with 4 kids running under my feet!). We ended up not having enough time to make them for Thanksgiving but made these Homemade Mini Pie Cupcakes for a family friends Christmas party instead.
I made it with a dozen egg cake recipe I found online. I had recently been given a dozen eggs from my daughter’s friend at school who’s family keeps chickens in their back yard so I was looking for a recipe that used a lot of eggs.
12 dozen eggs, 1 pound of butter, 4 cups of sugar, 4 cups of flour.. plus I added some spices, cinnamon, nutmeg, mace, a bit of ginger.
The frosting is just a basic butter cream. I used 1 lb of salted butter, about 6-8 cups of powdered sugar and instead of milk to thin I used eggnog to give it more of a festive taste. I also added a bit of freshly grated nutmeg (all organic ingredients for the cake and the frosting).
The “berry pies” are made with pomegranate, blueberry, and blackberry flavored jelly belly beans. For the “pumpkin pie” coloring I tinted the frosting with orange and brown Wilton gel coloring, more orange than brown and for the crust color I used the same gel coloring more brown and a bit of orange. I just experimented with different tips for different looks. And for the shot of “whipped cream” I used a star tip with plain white frosting.
They were a lot of fun to make! Everybody loved them and they were super cute.